Thoughtful Feedback After Switching to Arc Timeline & Arc Editor

Recently, I fully switched to Arc and I’m currently running both Arc Timeline and Arc Editor simultaneously. Before diving into specific feedback, I want to start with something important:

I genuinely love the old and the new currently in development app.

The concept and the ambition behind Arc clearly show a huge amount of dedication. Building something this detailed and thoughtfully designed while also maintaining it is not easy, and it really shows. Compliments for that.

That said, while using Arc more intensively, I came across a few small things I wanted to share. Mostly observations and suggestions that might help improve an already great experience.

1. Initial Location Occasionally Defaults to New York

Sometimes when I open the app for the first time in a day, Arc immediately places me in New York, even though I live in the Netherlands.

It doesn’t happen every time, but often enough to notice. It might be some kind of fallback location or cached state, but I thought it was worth mentioning.

2. Places Tab Goes Back to 1987

In the Places tab (the middle tab), it’s possible to scroll all the way back to 1987.

I’m not sure if this is intentional, but I’m guessing there aren’t many users who were already generating usable location data back then :grinning_face_with_smiling_eyes:

Not a big issue at all. just something that stood out and might be worth validating or limiting based on actual data availability.

3. Import Accuracy: Spain vs. France

During my data import, I noticed something interesting:

  • Arc Editor correctly detected that I traveled to Spain last year

  • However, it didn’t register that I spent almost two weeks in France last year on the way to Spain

It might be related to how longer stays versus transit moments are interpreted, but I wanted to flag it just in case.

4. Feature Suggestion: Yearly Overview / “Life Cycle”-Style Insights

One feature I would personally love is a yearly overview, similar to a “life cycle” or year-in-review concept:

  • Comparing how often certain activities were done compared to the previous year

  • Seeing whether I walked more, traveled more, or drove more

  • Visual trends rather than just raw data

Along the same lines, it could be really interesting to integrate sleep data from Apple Health. That would make Arc feel even more like a complete daily life overview.

It would also allow insights like:

  • How often you slept at a specific place

  • How travel or routines impact sleep patterns

5. Map Overview per Activity (Full-Year View)

One of the most fascinating things I’ve seen in the old version of the apps and currently not in the new app is a map overview of a single activity across an entire year.

For example:

  • All car trips from the past year shown on one map

  • All walks or runs combined into a single visual

Seeing those patterns spatially is incredibly powerful and gives a unique perspective on how you actually move through the world.

Final Thoughts

None of the above are dealbreakers, quite the opposite. They come from genuinely enjoying the app and wanting to see how far it can go.

Thanks for building it and for clearly caring about every detail.

2 Likes

Hi @ladupho! Thanks for the feedback! I’ll work through them in order.

This is one I’ve never seen before, for any location. I’m not sure what that means at all. You’re also the first person to mention seeing it! Most strange.

There shouldn’t be anything special about New York - it’s not in the app anywhere at all. Though I guess the Mapbox SDK might have some internal hardcoded NYC reference. Though if that were the cause, you’d think more of us would be seeing it.

Truly a mystery! I’ll ponder on it and see if anything comes to mind…

I just tried to reproduce this one, and this one I can! The calendar view won’t let me navigate to earlier than the existing data, but the previous page button does.

I’ll get this one fixed today. I bet it’s a super simple thing, missed one line of code. Thanks for the heads up!

Is this in the Places tab? If so this’ll be due to the country and city information needing to come from Apple’s “reverse geocode” service, which is rate limited. It can only fill in a limited number of places per minute. Then once it gets rate limited the rest fail, so backfilling stops at that point during import.

I’m going to fix this so that it keeps retrying, eventually backfilling all of them after import. But in the meantime you can tap through to either the days in Timeline tab or “unknown” places in Places tab, navigate into an Item Edit view for any place in the target day, and that will trigger another attempt to fill in the reverse geocode data for the places shown in that list.

That works per place rather than per visit. So for example if you stayed in the same hotel for one week, you only need to go to the edit view for one visit to that hotel, then Places tab’s stats will be correct for that full week.

Are you meaning like the flashy “year in review” kind of things that all the services are doing these days? If so, yeah I want that too! It’d be really fun to build too. I just haven’t found the time to build it yet. But I’ve got almost a whole year to get it done, in preparation for next year :joy:

You can get these two already in the Activity tab. Though at this point it’s limited to only a percentage difference per activity type. Not particularly exciting.

I’m going to do more work on Activity tab, fleshing it out more. Though possibly I’ll save that until after the v1.0 release - I really should get this shipped on the App Store proper, not just TestFlight. So I’m trying to limit my scope to just the essentials for the next month or so.

But yeah, charts, more stats, and more comparisons on Activity tab are high on my personal wishlist too!

I’ll also be doing the same for Timeline tab’s weekly, monthly, and yearly views. Right now their main content views are completely empty. But each of those ranges I think have interesting stats and data visualisations potentials. There’s going to be some fun stuff that can be done in those. And I’ll get to at least some of it before shipping v1.0. Can’t ship them completely empty like they are now!

You can already see this in a small way, so long as you’ve granted Arc access to that Health data type. On the Item Details view for any of your home visits, scroll down to the heart rate chart, and you’ll see the sleep periods coloured differently.

Though there’s certainly a lot more that could be done with sleep data. Hopefully I’ll get time to explore that more!

Not quite the same thing, but I recommend having a look at my other app, This & That. That calculates correlations between all health data types, including sleep. So you can see what correlates with more total sleep, more deep sleep, etc.

It’s not location aware yet (other than for fetching local weather reports, for correlating with weather patterns), but it does pick up many other factors that can influence sleep patterns.

Yeah I want this back too. The Activity tab is all ready to let you tap on the boxes and go to full stats views per activity, per range type. But I haven’t decided yet whether I’ll try to squeeze that work in before the v1.0 release or not. I want to, but I really do need to get v1.0 shipped soon. So it might end up being high on the list of things for v1.1.

Thanks again for all your feedback! Really glad you’re appreciating the apps! They’re a labour of live. This kind of data is really fun to work with and explore the possibilities.

1 Like

I see that sometimes too, most recently today (screenshot). This doesn’t bother me particularly, because the position corrects itself very quickly.

I’m familiar with this behaviour from another app/website that I use (https://globe.adsbexchange.com/). However, since it doesn’t have access to my location data, I suspected this behavior had something to do with Apple’s Core Location framework — similar to how the position locks onto streets even though the phone is clearly moving alongside them (since iOS18).